Good Lifestyle

HBO Max oriented Scooby Doo spin off Velma The show becomes ruthlessly planned by criticism and fans - but why? According to NPR TV Critical Eric Deggans , Velma is the perfect example of what is happening when a television show is "out of rails" thanks to factors such as lack of vision. "It is a dynamic a little different from what they had in original caricatures. And, you know, which has changed some fans who really like the franchise," he said.

The telegraph called Velma le " Most hated show on television "- But others say that Mindy Kaling, Velma's voice and executive producer of the series, is held according to impossible standards. This is why the show turned out to be so controversial.

Deggans believes Velma is during the game for not having shown enough respect for source equipment. "" Velma is an example of a television project that can really get out of the rails if there is no solid vision to explain why the show should exist in the first place. I mean, if you think of these live scooby-doo films, they have always been careful about how they modernized the characters because they knew that nostalgia was a great reason for which people show up for them . Now here, by changing the character so radically without real creative advantage, you end up with a program that removes the reason why fans have originally fell in love with the characters without giving them new reasons to worry about it. ""

Velma Was criticized for introducing too sexual adult themes, since the characters are supposed to be adolescents. "I think that if you look at it more widely, the show tries to accomplish many things that symbolize these major trends in modern television shows, and it fails in many," says Deggans.

"For example, Velma Try to modernize the characters in the Scooby-Doo universe by making them more cynical, more sexual and more self-centered. Velma herself is this strange pariah and avenger of the school who hates cool children and may have pushed her mother to leave her family. ""

"Kaling receives criticism from two different camps," said Deggans. "Now in modernization Velma , they did a few things that many television shows do these days. First of all, they changed the character's race. They made it South Asian like Kaling. And then they also show her to have a crush on a friend, leaning over these ideas that the character has always been gay. There are therefore fans who oppose the diversification of classic franchises in pop culture, complaining of the series too, quote "woke". But there are others who note the way Velma has this crush for Fred. This shows a South Asian woman in search of romance and validation of a white man. ""

Velma has a positive note of 50% among criticism and 6% among public members on Rotten Tomatoes. Kaling is one of the rare South Asian women in the industry, and some believe that it is held by unfair standards. "She has become a lightning rod for this kind of criticism", " said Lakshmi Srinivas , Associate Professor of American Asian Studies at the University of Massachusetts, Boston. Others emphasize that Kaling should represent a whole culture unreasonable.

"She is a [person]. We collectively criticize how people of color and bodies of color tend to always be representative of the collective and not of the individual. But that is exactly what we do to him by doing him Load to speak for all of us, ”explains Harleen Singh, associate professor of South Asian literature and female studies at the University of Brandeis.

"When his characters have become so popular with the general public, I think it is understandable that the South Asian community feels somewhat unworthy by this representation of an individual from South Asian", " Srinivas says .

"It is not inauthentic for the experience of the children of South Asia who grow up in this society. They face a lot of discrimination and a lot of intimidation at school. Their names are laughing at their food, of So that they could grow with this terrible defensive on this culture. They are almost the same as the characters that Mindy depicts. "